Nancy Godfrey (Judith Hoag) appeared in "To Kill A Legend" (S11E03) as the wife of antique store owner Tom Godfrey. Nancy was the killer of two people — Alexander Sansby and Amelia Farnham. She also created a scandal about Joshua Peabody, Cabot Cove's renowned hero, with film director Richard Hawkes. Nancy had Sansby forge George Washington's letter and later killed him. Amelia discovered her scandal and killed her too.
- Judith Hoag previously played Gretchen Price in season eight.